Saturday, October 15, 2022
HomeMust ReadWhat Is Better For Asthma Humidifier Or Air Purifier

What Is Better For Asthma Humidifier Or Air Purifier

Air Purifier And Humidifier Combo

Indoor Air Quality: Air Filters and Humidifiers

There are several devices out there that do both if you find that you really need both an air purifier and a humidifier. However, if you have issues with allergies and asthma due to the chemicals that are going around in their house, you do not need a humidifier. In reality, it can also make the situation worse to have moisture in the atmosphere.

Instead of getting an air purifier and humidifier combo to just save you room and a few bucks, what more you should be worried about is whether or not the air purification device has been clinically checked and approved to genuinely eliminate the pollutants that let them feel allergy symptoms and respiratory discomfort.

The Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America establishes guidelines that are developed by an independent medical advisory board when it is related to air purifiers. In order to be approved by the AAFA, it is important to objectively show that an air purifier eliminates a certain amount of pollutants from the air inside an enclosed room.

What Is The Difference Between An Air Scrubber And An Air Purifier

The main difference is that air scrubbers tend to remove fine dust particles from the air, while an air purifier filters out larger particles such as smoke, pollen, pet dander, and mold spores.

The air scrubber technology has the advantage of cleaning a more extensive space more quickly than an air purifying device can.

Air scrubbers are also more effective at removing mold spores, airborne contaminants, chemical vapors, odors, and gases. However, it does not trap or remove particles from the rooms surface like an air purifying device can.

Air purifiers are better for people with allergies or respiratory problems because they remove the smallest particles and dust mites that may be irritating your breathing space.

It is not as efficient at quickly cleaning a more ample space, making it more suitable for a house air purifier to function as an air cleaner filtering out toxic particles to improve indoor air quality.

Venta Lw25 Airwasher 2

This humidifier is perfect to cater the allergy issues as it works both as an air purifier and a humidifier. As the dirty and polluted air passes through its rotating moistened Disc Stacks, all airborne particles adhere to this Disc Stacks thus purifying the air. The unit only emits moistened air without any dust particles or pollens. The system does not use steam or water vapors to increase the humidity level and thus over humidification becomes impossible. The Humidifier works without any filter and can be used throughout the year without having to replace the filters.


  • Combines both an air washer and humidifier.
  • Doesn√Ęt emit white dust.
  • 2-gallon water reservoir.
  • Have to use demineralized water to prevent the limescale buildup.
  • Bit pricey.
  • Don’t Miss: Homemade Salt Inhaler

    Air Purifiers Vs Humidifiers

    When it comes to exploring the topic of air purifiers vs humidifiers, its important to get down to how each of them works beginning with air purifiers, which are devices that trap and remove contaminants from the air. Most air purifiers work by sucking air through the machine, where it passes through a series of filters that effectively trap any airborne irritants.

    There are other types of air purifiers on the market, including those using negative or bipolar ionization, carbon filtration, and ultraviolet light to filter the air. However, the jury is out on the efficacy of such devices, so weve focused here on filter-based humidifiers.

    The majority of commercial filter-based air purifiers have a high efficiency particulate air filter. The HEPA filter standard was developed in the 1940s for facilities containing nuclear materials before finding a commercial market in the 1960s.

    HEPA filters are built from a mesh of plastic and fiberglass threads woven together to stop contaminants from creeping through. Theyre capable of capturing particles as small as 0.3 microns and can remove a huge range of particles, including irritants and allergens such as dust, bacteria, mold, and more. HEPA filters don’t remove viruses completely, if you’re wondering, but they do have an effect on them.

    Vaporizer Vs Humidifier Which One Is Best For Asthma Patients

    What Is Better For Your Asthma, A Humidifer Or Air Purifier?

    Both vaporizer and humidifier disperse the moisture into the air. The major difference between a humidifier and a vaporizer is that humidifier emits cool water particles into the air for increasing the humidity level of a room. These units are more expensive and require more extensive cleaning. The mold and mildew can develop inside the tank that can contaminate the air of the room.While on the other hand, a vaporizer emits warm steam into the air making the atmosphere comfortable and soothing.

    The boiling water kills the bacteria or other pathogens in the water and thus emit more clean steam. Inhalants like balms, herbs and other medicinal plant extracts can be added into the water that can be inhaled by the patient giving instant relief from congestion. Vaporizers also make the room warm and comfortable in winters. So patients with asthma can make use of the clean air and soothing atmosphere. Vaporizers are also more cost-effective than other humidifiers.

    Don’t Miss: What Type Of Asthma Do I Have

    Which One Is Better For Baby

    You can use both products in case you have a baby in the household.

    If you decide to get an air purifier, that will provide your baby cleaner air in the room and promote better health than without it. If the air is dry, a humidifier will implement moisture to help your baby breathe and feel more comfortable than before.

    Wheezing: Air Purifier Or Humidifier

    “Wheezing is generally caused by inflammation or constriction of your airways,” says Dr. Bailey. The most common causes are asthma, the common cold, or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease .

    COPD is a group of inflammatory lung diseases that includes chronic bronchitis and emphysema. Smoking is the biggest risk factor for COPD, and coughing and shortness of breath are some of the main symptoms.

    First, see a doctor to determine the cause of your wheezing. If it’s asthma or COPD, go for an air purifier. “Any airborne particulates, like pet dander, dust, and pollen can make the inflammation and narrowing of the air passage worse,” Dr. Bailey says. “This would cause further congestion and louder wheezing. By removing these particulates with a purifier, it removes that risk of worsening your condition.”

    If your wheezing is from a cold, a humidifier can help reduce congestion in your nose and chest. And that’ll help you breathe easier.

    Recommended Reading: Can Smoking Weed Help Asthma

    Victsing 300ml Cool Mist Humidifier

    This humidifier is not just a humidifier but also a diffuser. You can add a few drops of your favorite essential oil or medicinal extracts in water and let the aroma spread in a room with the cool mist that would make the air refreshing. The humidifier comes with an automatic shutoff system in case of low water. With its 300 ml capacity, it can keep working for 6-8 hours nonstop. The Humidifier is ideal for small spaces.

    Pros1. Comes with an essential oil diffuser.2. Small and portable.3. Automatically shut off when water is decreased from the required limit.4. Cost effective.1. Small capacity works well in the smaller area.2. No filters so need more cleaning.

    Should I Choose An Air Scrubber Or Air Purifier

    Air Purifiers VS Humidifiers (Air Purifier Benefits VS Humidifier Benefits)

    It depends on your needs, but we recommend using an air purifier if you want to improve indoor air quality and remove toxic particles with a house air purifier. Improving air quality will help people who suffer from allergies or asthma and anyone else who wants to breathe healthier, fresher, smelling indoor air.

    You May Like: Asthma No Inhaler What To Do

    When Should You Choose An Air Purifier Over Humidifier

    • If youre suffering from allergies caused by pet dander, dust mites, or pollen, a humidifier wont be of much use to you. In such circumstances, you will want to invest in a good air purifier to rid your indoor environment of the allergens floating around in the air. This will prevent the airborne contaminants from reaching your eyes, lungs, or throat.
    • You need an air purifier if youre looking to rid your home of smoke emanating from cigarettes or fireplaces
    • If youre looking to reduce indoor dust particles and prevent them from settling on your furniture and appliances, we endorse air purifiers over humidifiers
    • To prevent a recurrence of severe respiratory conditions like asthma, you will want to get yourself an air purifier
    • If you own a pet, you need an air purifier to get rid of pet dander, odors, and germs that might be brought into the house by these animals.
    • If your house reeks of disinfectants and varnish, you will require an air purifier capable of removing volatile organic compounds.
    • An air purifier will also go a long way in eliminating stale air from your indoor environment
    • If youre living with a severe chest condition like chronic obstructive pulmonary disease or emphysema, you require investing in a good air filter capable of filtering dust, pollen, and tobacco smoke
    • Do you often snore? Airborne allergens could be causing a blockage in your respiratory system. Get yourself an air purifier to eliminate such allergens.

    When Is A Humidifier Preferable Over An Air Purifier

    • A humidifier best handles sinuses and nosebleeds. This is especially true when you discover that your respiratory issues are worsened by dry air and same goes for children who have congestion during cold winter months.
    • We recommend using humidifiers in the winter when the air is dehydrated. During the winter, you probably turn up the heat to combat the cold, which, unfortunately, saps the atmospheres moisture. Heated air within a home dries out your nasal passage and prevents your nose from supplying the required humidity to the lungs.
    • If your skin often dries out, cracks, and gets irritated, you should make sure your indoor humidity is maintained and if not then invest in a good humidifier. A humidifier could be the one thing you need to get relief from itchy skin caused by skin conditions such as eczema. Same goes for babys skin that can suffer from the lack of humid air.

    Also Check: Side Effects Of Nebulizer

    What Is An Air Scrubber

    A scrubbing system that uses a chemical to clean the air is known as an air scrubber. Its frequently used to eliminate odors, mold spores, exhaust fumes, and gas emissions .

    Negative ions are created when an electric current is passed through the air. Air scrubbers clean the air by using ionization. These negative ions attach to the positive particles in the room like dust, pollen, and smoke.

    These negative ions can then be collected with a metal plate or fan that blows them away from your breathing space, where they will not cause you any harm. Air scrubbers work best in small rooms that have minimal airflow.

    The cleaned air is released back into your room as fresh air.

    How Do Humidifiers And Air Purifiers Impact Your Health

    Humidifier Vs Air Purifier

    According to the EPA, indoor air can be two to five times more polluted than outdoor air. It would only make sense that increasing the indoor air quality by using air purifiers would have an effect on our health.

    On the other hand, EPA also starts their Use And Care Of Home Humidifiers factsheet with these words:

    Humidifiers are commonly used in homes to relieve the physical discomforts of dry nose, throat, lips, and skin.

    We see that there is some indication that humidifiers too help up in several ways. Well look at scientific studies to get a picture of what conditions might the use of air purifier and/or humidifiers be useful for:

    Recommended Reading: Aspirin Induced Asthma

    Which Is Better Air Humidifier Vs Air Purifier

    Choosing the right wellness device for your home sounds like a daunting task. With so many choices, you may find yourself questioning their validity with thoughts like: what do I actually need? or which device is the best choice for my family?

    These are all valid questions, and we plan to help you determine which is the better device for your home: an air humidifier or an air purifier.

    Air Purifiers Vs Humidifiers: How Do They Affect Air Quality

    Besides investigating how they work, the most important thing to establish with air purifiers vs humidifiers is how each device affects the air youre breathing. Starting with purifiers, where the obvious purpose is to improve air quality, which they do by filtering out particles.

    Research suggests that air purifiers can have a clinical benefit, but as with anything you get what you pay for. An evidence review from Current Allergy and Asthma reports that “Inexpensive, low-efficiency HVAC filters offer no better particle removal than no filter”.

    The lesson? Invest in a better-quality machine with a HEPA filter. HEPA filters are used in clinical settings such as hospitals and work at incredible levels of efficiency, trapping up to 99.97% of particles, according to the Environmental Protection Agency.

    The emergence of COVID-19 has raised awareness of the potential for airborne threats. While still cautious of a purifiers ability to stop the spread of colds, flu, and coronaviruses, SAGE has “medium confidence” that air-cleaning devices such as purifiers offer health benefits in spaces that arent well ventilated.

    Humidifiers are used to add moisture to the air, making the room feel more comfortable, particularly for those with health conditions, such as dry skin, irritations, and allergies. Air purifiers can help with allergies too.

    Read Also: Does Ibuprofen Make Asthma Worse

    When To Use A Humidifier

    When it comes to a humidifier, you will definitely know when to use it.

    It is easy to figure out when the air in your home is too dry. If you are not sure, here is one of my posts that will help you indetermining the humidity levels in your home without an expensive tool.

    Unless you live in a region where the dry air is a constant problem, you will have this issue just during the winter.

    The air is already dry outside, and when the heating kicks in, it only becomes dryer.

    This, for most people, is a problem.

    Humidifier Vs Air Purifier The Differences

    BEST Humidifier and air purifier to buy | Best of 2020

    The first thing I was wondering when I started the whole problem with the air and solution situation was what is the difference between a humidifier and an air purifier? Arent they the same thing?

    I mean, I heard about both before, but just assumed that they are sort of the same appliance, only with some small differences. They both have the same purpose, dont they?

    But, I was way wrong about that. They are not the same. In fact, they have completely different purposes and the choice actually depends on the problem you have.

    So, if you happen to have a problem with bad air, the chances are high that you have mold somewhere. And a humidifier would only make it worse.

    Humidifiers are meant to add moisture into the air in areas where the air is too dry and causes health problems.

    An air purifier, on the other hand, purifies the air. It doesn’t add or take away moisture, it simply removes the pollutant particles from the air.

    So, before making the final choice, make sure you have thoroughly inspected your house, checked all the materials and spots.

    This way, you will know what the source of the bad smell is. And you will know which appliance to choose and not make the whole problem even worse.

    You May Like: How Does An Asthma Attack Feel

    Price Of Humidifiers Vs Air Purifiers

    There is also a large difference between it comes to humidifiers vs air purifiers in their cost.

    Humidifiers are quite inexpensive. They usually cost less than $100, depending on the model.

    Air purifiers can be much more expensive. Its not unusual to pay more than $500 for one of the best air purifiers. Example: Molekule Air, best Dyson air purifiers, Airdog X5, Alen BreatheSmart 75i, and the best Coway air purifier cost more than $500.

    Of course, there are cheaper brands of air purifiers like Hathaspace, Okaysou, Winix, and Levoit, to name a few. These can cost as little as $100.

    What needs to be additionally considered when buying an air purifier is the continuous cost of replacement filters. HEPA filters and activated carbon filters need to be replaced several times per year costs of that can easily rise above $100 per year.

    Some companies do produce both air purifiers and humidifiers. This might be a potential reason why people have a harder time distinguishing between air humidifiers and purifiers they are made by the same company.

    In order to properly differentiate between air purifiers and humidifiers, we have created this summary comparison table:

    Air Purifiers Versus Humidifiers How Air Purifiers And Humidifiers Work

    Provided that the purpose of the two instruments is drastically different, their functioning is also somewhat different. Through using filters that serve as sieves, an air purifier functions.

    The undesirable particles and contaminants inside them are captured by these sieve-like filters, which disperse filtered and clean air through the house.

    But on the other side, a humidifier functions by releasing water vapor into the air in the room. It does so by converting the water that is placed into the system into vapors of water which were then distributed into the air around it.

    You May Like: Marines Asthma

    Respiratory Irritation Flu And Cold

    Air Purifiers Remember that standard air purifiers can capture small particles in the air, and some of them may carry tiny viruses that cannot pass the usual filters that you are using. Even though it cannot help with an existing cold that you developed, it may help you ease the symptoms by reducing and completely removing other irritants that will affect your respiratory conditions.

    Air Humidifiers According to experts, a humidifier can help you relieve discomfort of flu and colds and help you with a stuffy nose. At the same time, balanced levels of humidity are the first line of protection against airborne viruses. According to some studies, having humidity between 40 and 60 percent will reduce the possibility of getting a virus. However, it cannot cure you when you are sick, but it will help you relieve the symptoms and prevent scratchy throat, nose and dry skin.


    Most Popular