Saturday, October 15, 2022
HomePopularDoes Breathing Into A Paper Bag Help Asthma

Does Breathing Into A Paper Bag Help Asthma

Treatment Of Hypocapnia And Hyperventilation

Does Breathing into a Paper Bag Actually Help with Anxiety Attacks?

The treatment of hypocapnia/respiratory alkalosis depends on the underlying cause.

Symptoms of hyperventilation can be similar to the symptoms of other serious health conditions, which is why its paramount to seek medical help if you experience them.

Some options your doctor might bring up for hyperventilation- and anxiety-related causes are covered below.

These strategies should only be used if a doctor has confirmed the exact cause of hyperventilation.

Why Do Panic Attacks Happen

Panic attacks can happen to anyone, without any obvious cause or warning. They can be extremely alarming both for the person experiencing the attack and anyone trying to help

Exams increase stress and children and teenagers up and down the country will be sitting in exams halls, waiting to hear the famous words you can turn your papers over now. For some, exams cause no problems at all, many just get butterflies, but for some, the fear of exams can result in full blown panic attacks. .

Certain times of life can make people more prone to panic attacks, often those going through menopause experience them and early Alzheimers can also result in a higher incidence. Increased stress and overload can often be a contributory factor. However, there does not need to be any obvious reason sometimes, they just happen!

Does It Have To Be A Paper Bag

Yes. Always use a small paper bag, not a plastic one. A plastic bag doesnt work the same way and can be dangerous.

The thin plastic can get sucked into your mouth when youre breathing in. This can be especially dangerous for smaller children and older adults.

The paper bag technique wont help an asthma attack and can even make it worse, because you may not get enough oxygen into your body.

Dont use this breathing technique if you have any heart or lung conditions.

Also, breathing can be more difficult than normal if youre at a high altitude. Breathing into a paper bag wont help with elevation changes in breathing.

Only use the bag method if youre sure youre having an anxiety attack. Other causes of hyperventilating include an asthma attack, fever, or other illnesses.

You might have other anxiety symptoms like:

  • shortness of breath

Read Also: Does Asthma Inhalers Cause Weight Gain

How Do You Breathe In A Brown Paper Bag

paper bagbagbagbag

The Claim: If You‘re Hyperventilating, Breathe Into a Paper Bag. Like a bandage for a cut or a crutch for a broken leg, the brown paper bag is a symbol for hyperventilation. Hyperventilation causes the body to expel too much carbon dioxide, and rebreathing exhaled air helps restore that lost gas.

Secondly, does breathing in a paper bag help asthma? The paper bag technique you mention is used when a person hyperventilates, as in a panic attack, which leads to low levels of carbon dioxide in the blood . While sometimes appropriate for panic attacks, it is not appropriate for asthma attacks.

Keeping this in view, how long should you breathe into a paper bag?

If hyperventilation continues for longer than 30 minutes, call your doctor immediately.Using a Paper Bag to Control Hyperventilation

  • Take 6 to 12 easy, natural breaths, with a small paper bag held over your mouth and nose.
  • Next, try belly-breathing .
  • How does breathing into a paper bag help return blood pH to normal?

    Respiratory alkalosis is a condition in which the pH of the blood is above normal. Respiratory alkalosis is treated by having the hyperventilating person breathe into a paper bag. In doing so, they rebreathe some of expelled carbon dioxide, and blood carbon dioxide levels return to normal.

    Asthma Uk Community Forum

    Treating Hyperventilation by Breathing Into a Paper Bag

    Someone told me today that breathing into a paper bag helps during asthma attacks. I’m not convinced – I hyperventilate during attacks but that’s only because I cant breathe deep enough, not because I’m panicing. What is the role of CO2, and what does an asthma attack do to it? Isn’t this the week of a million questions from me…

    Paper bags don’t really have a role in managing asthma attacks, althought this is a common misconception. Breathing into a paper bag can help in a *panic* attack.

    There are a couple of gases which are important to consider when you’re talking about what happens in an asthma attack – Oxygen and Carbon Dioxide . Both are important gases in your blood – you need oxygen for your cells to function, muscles to work etc etc, and CO2 is also important to have in your bloodstream to keep the blood at the right pH . CO2 is considered a “”waste”” gas, as your cells produce it when they function, and you get rid of it by breathing it out.

    In an asthma attack, you tend to overbreathe . The net effect of this is that you blow off/get rid of more CO2 and the levels of O2 in your blood go up. This can make you feel light headed with perhaps tingly fingers/toes and lips. People can get similar symptoms when they panic and hyperventilate, and by breathing into a paper bag they re-breathe this CO2 that they’ve just breathed out, which helps to correct the levels in the blood.

    Hope that makes sense.

    Also Check: How To Treat Asthma Attack Without An Inhaler

    How Anxiety Affects Asthma

    For some people anxiety, stress and strong emotion are triggers for asthma. For others it is the asthma that causes the anxiety. Breathing problems can cause you to feel anxious because struggling to breathe is frightening. Sometimes people with asthma can be told that their symptoms are anxiety related and not asthma related.Parents of children with asthma, or carers of adults with asthma, can feel anxious, particularly at the point of diagnosis, or if the asthma is poorly managed.Anxiety and asthma can often occur together setting up a cycle where it is difficult to get back in control.Keeping control of your asthma, with regular asthma reviews and the correct treatment, is one key way to break this cycle. If you have asthma and are going through a stressful time you need to keep a closer eye on your asthma symptoms.If you are confident that your asthma is well managed it will be less a source of anxiety for you. Finding ways to overcome your anxiety is another way to break the cycle and the organisations we have listed at the end of this fact file will be able to give you advice and help.

    Breath Training: Asthmatic Children

    Breath retraining has been used in yoga and meditations for centuries to refocus and rejoin the mind and breath. Connecting the mind and breath has positive physiological and psychological implications and has been shown to effectively control anxiety. A study from the Childrens Hospital in Germany analyzed the efficacy of implementing Buteyko breathing techniques as a treatment for children with asthma. They observed that breath retraining focuses on the patients breathing pattern as dysfunctional breathing and stated that it is this dysfunctional breathing that leads to hyperventilation as well as mental and physical health problems . After conducting a three-month Buteyko training program on thirty-two children diagnosed with moderate to severe asthma, they concluded that there were notable improvements in lung function. The children increased the time spent in the controlled pause indicating better control of their respirations.

    Don’t Miss: How To Calm Down Asthma Symptoms

    Paper Bag Technique Is Not First Aid For Asthma

    Asthma is a respiratory condition that afflicts 2.7 million people in Australia this amounts to around one in every 9 Australians .

    One person in 9 could mean one of your family members, friends, co-workers, or neighbours And while many asthmatics are used to carrying their puffers, medication, and a copy of their asthma action plan, theres always the possibility youll witness an asthma attack where none of these 3 items are on hand.

    Lets take a closer look at asthma, hyperventilation, and the paper bag technique, a well-known method for treating breathlessness.

    Deep-breathing into a paper bag is recommended by health professionals, to counter the effects of hyperventilation from panic attacks. But could we use this paper bag technique for an asthma attack when an inhaler is not available?

    Take a breath now while we explain the important differences between breathing into a paper bag and breathing into an inhaler, and what first aid you should really do for an asthmatic when a puffers not available.

    Asthma Attacks Vs Panic Attacks: Know The Difference

    Why You Should Never Breathe into a Paper Bag for Panic Attacks and Anxiety (Do This Instead!)

    Despite sharing symptoms, an asthma attack and a panic attack are two totally different beasts. Their treatments are not interchangeable.

    A person experiencing a panic attack may have difficulty breathing, but unlike an asthmatic, their airways are not being obstructed. An asthmatics airways will be inflamed and filled with mucus, leading to coughing, wheezing, and laboured breathing. The problem for a panic attack victim is the lack of carbon dioxide.

    You can certainly inhale a greater proportion of carbon dioxide by deep-breathing into a paper bag. An asthmatics inhaler, on the other hand, is the delivery system for corticosteroids. Breathing in these cortisone-like medicines has the effect of relieving discomfort in the chest by reducing inflammation in the airways and arresting excess mucus production.

    Panic attacks and hyperventilation are occasions where breathing too much, too quickly, is the problem. With asthma, struggling to breathe, even a little, is the issue. If this is the case, forget the paper bag and go straight to first aid for asthma.

    Read Also: Asthma Marijuana

    What Happens When You Breathe In A Paper Bag

    YouBreathePaper Bagpaper bag

    . Similarly, what happens when you breathe into a paper bag?

    When the body receives more oxygen than it needs, the result can be what’s known as respiratory alkalosis . One of the most common causes is hyperventilating. The point of breathing into a bag is to re-breathe your exhaled carbon dioxide in the hopes of bringing your body back to a normal pH level.

    One may also ask, does breathing in a paper bag help anxiety? Paper bags:Do not suggest breathing in and out of a paper bag. People used to think breathing in and out of a paper bag was helpful during a panic attack, and the physiology makes sense breathing out in panic results in the loss of carbon dioxide in the blood and breathing into a bag restores the lost CO2.

    Furthermore, how long should you breathe into a paper bag?

    If hyperventilation continues for longer than 30 minutes, call your doctor immediately.Using a Paper Bag to Control Hyperventilation

  • Take 6 to 12 easy, natural breaths, with a small paper bag held over your mouth and nose.
  • Next, try belly-breathing .
  • How do you breathe into a paper bag?

    Do not breathe continuously into a paper bag. Take 6 to 12 natural breaths, with a paper bag held over your mouth and nose, then remove the bag from your nose and mouth. Do not hold the bag for the person who is hyperventilating. Allow the person to hold the bag over his or her own mouth and nose.

    Why Breathe Into A Paper Bag

    Mar 11, 2014 Since its inception, the paper bag has been manufactured in so Asthma is theresult of an inflammation that occurs in your bronchial tubes. be having a heartattack, do not reach for a paper bag to help pace . It should not be used as asubstitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment.

    Don’t Miss: How To Relieve Asthma Without Inhaler

    Let’s Try Buteyko Breathing

    The Buteyko technique uses a controlled pause. One is taken following exhalation, with each increase in five seconds of the pause being held indicating an improvement. With each successive week of training, the person will begin to feel as though their breath is lighter as they begin to take in more air and increase circulation within the body. Buteyko breathing consists of seven main exercises with several variations to each one. Choose the exercise that fits your life, comfort level, and goals the best. We will focus on the two most common Buteyko exercises that can be included in your daily routine or used during moments of stress and anxiety.

    Carbon Dioxide Theory Of Disease

    How Does Breathing In A Paper Bag Help Anxiety

    Dr. Buteyko developed his breathing method around a theory on carbon dioxide and disease. He believed that chronic illness and disease is caused by chronic hyperventilation that shifts the pH of the blood causing adverse physiological effects. Dr. Buteyko researched the complex metabolic reactions that occur at the cellular level and determined that the lack of carbon dioxide as a result of unconscious hyperventilation limits the Krebs cycle vital in producing energy and maintaining homeostasis within the body. The lack of carbon dioxide makes it impossible for the Krebs cycle to occur and severely limits the body’s ability to produce energy. Dr. Buteykos carbon dioxide theory states that it is this chemical reaction that leads to disease and thus, he began developing a breathing technique to better prevent hyperventilation.

    You May Like: What Happens If You Smoke Weed With Asthma

    Why Does Breathing Into A Paper Bag Help

    Breathing into a paper bag is a technique that can help you regulate hyperventilation. It works by putting some of the lost carbon dioxide back into your lungs and body. This helps to balance oxygen flow in your body.

    However, breathing into a paper bag must be done properly and may not work for everyone. Medical research on using it to help hyperventilation is divided on whether it really works.

    Some case studies dont recommend using this breathing technique.

    Other medical review studies find that breathing into a paper bag can help some patients with hyperventilation.

    To use a paper bag to help you breathe when youre hyperventilating, follow these steps:

    • Hold a small paper bag over your mouth and nose.
    • Take 6 to 12 normal breaths.
    • Remove the bag from your mouth and nose.
    • Take a few breaths.

    The Claim: If Youre Hyperventilating Breathe Into A Paper Bag

    • Read in app
    • May 13, 2008


    Like a bandage for a cut or a crutch for a broken leg, the brown paper bag is a symbol for hyperventilation.

    Grabbing a bag and breathing into it repeatedly, known in medical literature as rebreathing, has long been recommended to ease rapid, uncontrolled breathing. Some doctors even keep bags in the office for that reason. But most medical studies and experts suggest that the method, though accepted, is dangerous and should be retired.

    The idea behind it is to increase carbon dioxide levels. Hyperventilation causes the body to expel too much carbon dioxide, and rebreathing exhaled air helps restore that lost gas.

    The problem is that several medical conditions, like asthma and heart attacks, can be confused with hyperventilation. In such cases reducing oxygen and increasing carbon dioxide can be deadly. One study in The Annals of Emergency Medicine described three cases in which people having heart attacks thought, wrongly, that they were hyperventilating and died after losing oxygen while breathing into bags.

    Another study said using a bag was no better at easing hyperventilation than using an open tube. For better results, experts say, stay calm and practice breathing slowly and deliberately.


    Most studies advise against paper bags to treat hyperventilation.

    Don’t Miss: Do Essential Oils Trigger Asthma

    How Do You Calm Someone With An Anxiety Attack

    Topic Overview

  • Stay with the person and keep calm.
  • Offer medicine if the person usually takes it during an attack.
  • Dont make assumptions about what the person needs.
  • Speak to the person in short, simple sentences.
  • Be predictable.
  • Help slow the persons breathing by breathing with him or her or by counting slowly to 10.
  • What Is A Panic Attack

    Why Breathing Into a Paper Bag Can Be Harmful

    A panic attack strikes patients suddenly, accompanied by a feeling of intense terror and a fear of imminent danger. In most cases of panic attacks, theres no particular, specific reason. However, research has shown that in many cases, panic attacks dont result from anxiety and fear, but rather from abnormal breathing.

    Although some of the commonly observed symptoms of a panic attack include a rapidly pounding heart, chest pain, dizziness etc. , the one symptom that you find in every single case of a panic attack is shortness of breath, which further leads to hyperventilation .

    Read Also: How To Control Asthma Attacks Without Inhaler

    Heres How To Use An Inhaler

  • Remove the cap from the mouthpiece and inspect it for residue or blockages.
  • Shake the inhaler vigorously for a few seconds.
  • Take a deep breath and then exhale completely.
  • While standing or sitting upright, begin to breathe in slowly with the inhaler in place and press the button. Continue breathing in after pressing it.
  • Hold your breath for 5 to 10 seconds, then breathe out slowly through your mouth.
  • Knowing Your Asthma Action Plan Is Step One

    For most people with asthma, managing the chronic condition involves a multi-pronged approach tailored to your symptoms and lifestyle.

    Step one for everyone, however, is having a firm grasp of your asthma action plan.

    Work with your doctor to create an asthma action plan that covers how to:

    In addition, monitor your symptoms carefully. Keep track of what they are, when they occur, and their severity.

    Journal of Asthma and Allergy,

    • In cold, dry air
    • In environments with airborne irritants, such as cigarette smoke

    You May Like: Nebulizer Medications Side Effects

    What Is Buteyko Breathing

    Buteyko is a method of breathing that decreases the respiration rate, that is reducing the amount of breaths taken each minute to slow the breathing and ensure that inhalation occurs solely through the nose. It emphasises the effortless quiet breathing completed by healthy individuals. This method uses the addition of a controlled pause following exhalation to train the respiratory system to take in less air and calm the breath. Buteyko breathing is similar to other yogi breathing techniques as it directs the breath aligning the mind and body. It utilizes a controlled pause which is timed to better understand the respiratory capacity and manipulate the oxygen dissociation curve to attain maximal health benefits.


    Most Popular