Saturday, October 15, 2022
HomeEditor PicksWhich Is Better For Asthma Humidifier Or Vaporizer

Which Is Better For Asthma Humidifier Or Vaporizer

Best For Whole House: Aircare Ma1201 Humidifier

Bacteria-breeding Humidifiers | Consumer Reports

This Vicks model boils water into a steam vapor, which reviewers say is remarkably effective at moisturizing the air. Its also user-friendly, with no filter, easy cleaning, a soft night light, and an automatic shut-off function for when it runs out of water. It also includes a cup for liquids like Vicks VapoSteam, making it ideal for anyone with a cold who wants a little more out of their humidifier. You wont have to worry about getting up constantly, either, since its tank lasts up to 24 hours on a single fill.

Which Is Better Forallergies: Humidifiers Or Vaporizers

While both can provide measurablebenefits, the AAAI suggests thatusing humidifiers to fight indoor allergies might becounterproductive. As a result, a vaporizer may be the best choicefor those who suffer from allergies in the home. Because vaporizersboil the water to create steam, the air is cleaner than ahumidifier. You can also further reduce allergies by adding certainessential oils. Lavender, for instance, is known for itsanti-inflammatory properties, and you can use a vaporizer torelease this oil into the air.

What Is The Difference Between An Air Purifier And A Humidifier

An air purifier is used to clean the air by removing or otherwise inactivating pollutants from the air. The two basic components of an air purifier are a fan and a filter surface, though the specific filtration technology can vary, from traditional HEPA filters to ionizers to brand-new PECO technology. In most air purifiers, air is passed through the unit, pollutants are trapped or removed on a filter and clean air is emitted back into the room. Air purifiers do not add any moisture to the air.

A humidifier, on the other hand, does not clean the air. It simply adds water to the air by boiling water into steam, vibrating water droplets into the air with ultrasonic technology, or by evaporating the water using a fan and a wick. Note that ultrasonic humidifiers might also introduce tiny mineral particles into the air if tap water is used instead of distilled water. The health effects of these particles are not very well known, but research suggests that they could have some effects on lung tissue . The EPA recommends using distilled water and regularly cleaning and disinfecting your humidifier.

Don’t Miss: What To Do When Having An Asthma Attack

How Does An Air Purifier Help

An air purifier is designed to improve indoor air quality by getting rid of airborne contaminants such as VOCs, dust, or pollen. Although these appliances are sometimes referred to as air filters, many air purifiers work by means of other processes like ionization.

While many sources can contaminate the air of your home, some of the most common examples are:

  • Dust and dust mites very irritating, particularly to someone already prone to allergies or asthma.
  • Pet dander actually more problematic than fur shedding.
  • Mould spores
  • Formaldehyde an ingredient in the glue used for many household furnishings and materials
  • Emission from fuel-powered combustion appliances, such as furnaces or gas stoves
  • Tobacco smoke

TIP: Different types of air purifiers have different capabilities. Talk with one of our indoor air quality specialists about the best model for your specific situation. Be sure to mention if a family member suffers from a respiratory problem such as allergies, asthma, or emphysema.

How Does A Humidifier Help

Portable Handheld humidifier for Kids & Adults Home Daily ...

A humidifier will add moisture to indoor air which is overly dry that is, below 30% relative humidity, the minimum recommended humidity level. You can actually measure relative humidity with a simple, inexpensive gadget called a hygroscope. Dry air in your home is most common during the winter, due to the drying effects of our heating systems.

Small freestanding humidifiers like the type used for childhood illnesses are available. However, for more convenient, effective results, installation of a whole-home furnace humidifier is preferable.

Also Check: What Happens If You Have Asthma

How Does A Humidifier Help With Asthma

Asthma symptoms can be alleviated by better quality air which is why humidifiers can make a remarkable difference in the management of this chronic disease. Asthma can cause nasal passages to become dry and a humidifier can moisten these airways, allowing for stronger breathing.

Symptoms of asthma can be maintained by the use of humidifiers and may even limit the number of asthma attacks an individual experiences. The devices can ease dry throat and mouth discomfort through humidity, as well as lessen the stress of an individual who suffers from asthmatic symptoms, lessening worries of a flare up.

Maintaining a comfortable nasal cavity can keep stress at bay and minimize symptoms, as your mind isnt constantly triggering your muscles to contract in response to stress.

Humidifier Or Dehumidifier For A Stuffy Nose

A stuffy nose can be a symptom that accompanies a common allergy and might take a couple of days to settle. One way of handling stuffy nose is to use a humidifier. Adding water vapour to the air will help to relieve blockage in the nose or any congestion. Hence the answer is âYes, a humidifier will help with the stuffy noseâ. However, this isnât the case with dehumidifiers. Although high humidity makes it difficult to breathe, but too much removal of moisture and dry air could worsen a stuffy nose.

You May Like: Asthma Weight Gain

Best For Nurseries: Pure Enrichment Mistaire Cloud

Plugging in too many devices can be a drain on your energy bill and your available outlets; if you know you want an air purifier, too, skip the hassle and combine them with Sharps Plasmacluster. Beloved by reviewers and Prevention editors alike, it shows your rooms humidity level on an easy-to-read display and cleans your air while hydrating it. This device automatically adjusts the humidity setting based on temperaturethe higher the temperature, the less itll humidify, one reviewer explains. Were pretty happy so far.

So Which Humidifier Should You Use

Bacteria-Breeding Humidifiers

Before you purchase a humidifier for your home, it is better to be clear on their types and difference. There are two types of humidifiers; warm mist and cool mist. Each type is equally effective in carrying out its function; the difference lies in the temperature of the mist. Cool mist humidifiers are advised when one wants to treat breathing difficulties or asthma in children. It is also considered to be a safer option for children, in the event of spills.

Read Also: Homemade Inhaler Spacer

Pick Your Vaporizer From The Updated List Below

We can use vaporizers and humidifiers to avoid such problems, but there are many differences. For many as a general user, it is a dilemma to know which is the most effective.

We will not tell you directly, which will be best for you. It is because fundamental differences do exist in their effectiveness. We will show you how these two devices work in different diseases. The next, the decision is yours alone.

Usage Of A Humidifier And A Vaporizer

Vaporizers inhale extracts from plants or other foreign sources, providing health benefits. Also, a vaporizer is useful for extracting plant plants and herbs essences for inhalation. Humidifiers are most useful in winter climates and when the air is dry and cold. A vaporizer is perfect for use at night as it eases the dryness and stuffiness of nasal passages. Most users prefer to use them at night to get comfortable sleeping hours.

Furthermore, avoid using the vaporizer throughout the day to prevent filing the air with too much moisture. Having excess moisture in the air may lead to fungus or mold growth in the room. Proper usage will reduce the risk of respiratory issues occurring in the future. Its vital to keep your room humidity level below 50%, purchase an interior hygrometer to measure the humidity in the air.

The humidifier and vaporizer will also need to be maintained regularly for them to function correctly. Depending on the make and model you settle for. Read the instruction manuals carefully for assistance. For better results and care of your vaporizer, use distilled water. Tap water contains minerals that may clog up the machine and ruin its functionality. Do not overfill the tank to avoid spills, use the fill line as a guideline on where to keep the water level.

Read Also: What Can Asthma Do To You

Air Purifiers Or Humidifier: Which Is Useful To Whom

The answer to this question depends on the different circumstances.

You should opt for an air purifier if:

  • You have allergies, asthma, or any other respiratory conditions related to inhaling contaminated air.
  • You want a cleaner, more sterilized home environment.
  • You wish to decrease the number of allergens from your homes air.
  • You want to get rid of foul odors of cooking, smoke, or pets.
  • You want to get a night of better sleep with less throat and lung irritation.
  • You want to decrease the amount of dust that collects indoors.
  • You want to reduce the toxic substances from the surrounding.

You should opt for a humidifier if:

  • You live in very dry climate regions.
  • You like to increase the level of moisture in your homes air.
  • You have a very dry skin, eyes, or hair during the winter season.
  • You want some relief from all respiratory problems that are caused to dry air.
  • You have an excessive snoring problem at night that is caused by the surrounding dry air.

Vaporizer Vs Humidifier For Allergy:

Humidifier for Asthma: Pros and Cons

Red rashes on the body are one of the most common symptoms of allergies. Usually, people get allergies due to the dusty environment. Again several foods can cause our allergies when eaten.

It is excruciating and uncomfortable. So people try different ways to survive allergies. To stay away from allergies, we must keep our indoor air free from dust and dirt. For this, we can use and humidifier.

  • Save

It is essential here because it helps keep the right amount of humidity in the air in our house. By using it again, we can stay free from allergies. But in all these cases it is most useful. It is because it can give a balanced humidity to the air in the house and the air in the home.

As a result, the dust and dirt in the houses atmosphere cannot affect our lungs. The humidifier absorbs dust and germs from the air. It can help keep your bodys immune system in check.

These also help to create healthy mucus levels inside your body, especially in your nose and throat. Here, one study found that this healthy mucus prevents germs from entering our bodies.

As a result, our lungs are healthy and sound. So, if a humidifier gets used to maintain the houses humidity and keep it free from germs, it should get kept clean regularly.

Also Check: What To Do During An Asthma Attack No Inhaler

What Do Air Purifiers Do Vs What Do Humidifiers Do

When it comes to indoor air, we usually have two major inconveniences:

  • Air pollutants like dust, pollen, smoke, and other allergens. We want to remove those.
  • In the winter, air humidity falls to 20-30%. We want to lift it to a comfortable 40-50%.

Both an air purifier and a humidifier affect the state of indoor air.

Humidifier: Basics Knowledge And Its Functionality

Humidifier |Photo Credit: Google Images

A humidifier is a device which works best in adding moisture in the room due to high humidity level. The main function of a humidifier is to pump the water vapor to add moisture back in the air of your room.

Chapped lips, nosebleeds, skin irritation, skin dryness, and persistent coughing are a few symptoms that occur when the indoor environment has too much of humidity. As per the Environmental Protection Agency standards, the indoor humidity level must be between 30-50%. Below 30% is too dry, and it can cause severe health issues. Over 50% humidity level can encourage mold growth, dust mite reproduction and mildew in the indoors.


Humidifiers function quite effectively and are most-part self-regulating. There is a little reservoir that holds cold water and dispenses it into a basin. The filter absorbs the water from the basin and then a fan blows air through the moistened filter.

As the air passes through the filter, it evaporates the water. The higher the relative humidity, the harder it is to evaporate water from the filter, which is why a humidifier is self-regulating as humidity increases, the humidifiers water-vapor output naturally decreases.

Read Also: How To Help Your Asthma Without An Inhaler

What Are Signs And Symptoms Of Asthma

Sometimes, the signs and symptoms of asthma begin before a full-blown attack starts. A few of the pre-attack symptoms include unusual exhaustion after physical exercise, trouble sleeping and nighttime coughing.

In the midst of an attack, coughing also occurs; however, coughing may be uncontrollable and experienced with shortness of breath, wheezing, chest tightness, anxiety, rapid breathing and even blue-tinted fingernails and lips as the persons oxygen level decreases.

Types Of Air Purifiers

Dr Anjali Bhaisin explains the difference between a Vaporizer & Humidifier

Air purifiers come in various types and each unit can contain one or more of the following air cleaning functions:

  • HEPA Filtration: This is a highly dense filter that traps airborne contaminants. A True HEPA Filter is the best kind to look for on an air purifier because its certified to remove 99.97% of all particles as small as 0.3 microns in size. Its good for removing pollutants like allergens, particulate matter, dust, visible smoke, and pet dander.
  • Carbon Filtration: This filter contains a special form of activated carbon that traps gases, odors, chemicals, and volatile organic compounds . It helps keep a home smelling fresh and reduces toxic substances that are in the air.
  • Negative Ionization:This air cleaning technology emits charged ions into the air that latch onto airborne contaminants. This process weights particles down so they can be more easily captured by the internal air filters as well as causes pollutants to fall onto the floor. This process can remove ultra-fine particles down to 0.01 microns in size.
  • Ultraviolet Light: This is a special light that kills airborne bacteria and viruses by destroying their molecular DNA structure. As air passes through the air purifier, the UV light zaps microorganisms and pathogens so that the air flowing back into the room is sterilized and clean.

Recommended Reading: What To Do During Asthma Attack Without Inhaler

How Humidifiers Can Help With Asthma Symptoms

Individuals living with asthma are well aware of the precise balance of humidity they require in the environment to breathe properly. If the air is too dry, one set of symptoms will crop up, and if the air is too humid, a whole new set of problems is ready to appear.

While asthma is a chronic condition that should only be treated by doctor-prescribed methods, there are a number of benefits in humidifiers for asthma afflicted individuals, so long as the unit is carefully selected for its environment and properly maintained.

Best Humidifier For Asthma And Allergies

November 22, 2020 By

Humidifiers are useful in controlling moisture levels in the air. They help increase humidity during the cold season when the air is incredibly dry. Asthma and some types of allergies are triggered by low humidity levels, and this article reviews the best humidifier for asthma and allergies.;

Humidifiers, do much more than release moisture into the air. Using a humidifier in your room can also reduce allergies, cold and alleviate asthma attacks.;The moisture released helps fight off bacteria and provides clean and soothing air for its users. If youre prone to allergies and asthma especially in cold weather you should consider getting a humidifier in your home.

However, not all humidifiers work effectively in alleviating asthma and allergies, we have reviewed the top five humidifiers that are considered perfect for asthma and allergies.;

Don’t Miss: Does Losing Weight Help Asthma

What Is Relative Humidity

Relative humidity is the rate of moisture the air is currently holding at a specific temperature versus the maximum moisture capacity of the air at the same temperature. When you see a relative humidity reading, its shown as a percentage.

For instance, a relative humidity of 30 percent means the air contains only 30 percent of the total water vapor it is capable of holding. Some humidifiers are equipped with a hygrometer, which is a tool that determines the airs moisture level while other humidifiers have a humidistat.

A humidistat takes the moisture-reading ability of the hygrometer a step further by not only measuring the relative humidity but also controlling it.

Varieties Of Humidifiers And Vaporizers

Difference Between Air Purifier and Humidifier Explained

Both these machines come in a variety of options and prices, so it comes down to preference. There are different types of models, so you can choose one that suits your purpose and convenience. Central humidifiers can easily hook on to the house`s heating equipment. It can receive water directly as it humidifies the entire house.

Tabletop and room humidifiers are small and will require you to fill them manually. Evaporative humidifiers are advanced, and they capture minerals and pollutants. One of the silent types of humidifiers includes the ultrasonic humidifiers. The ultrasonic version creates vapors using sound waves, giving them their quiet nature. Cool mist humidifiers use spinning discs and are the cheaper models of humidifiers available in the market.

Vaporizers are usually defined by the way they heat liquids. Some of the vaporizers heat liquids by thermal convection, radiation, or thermal conduction. Youll find portable versions that allow you to travel with them wherever you go. They can be handheld, and there`s also the electric versions that plug into a wall. Before placing one of the machines in a child`s room, it is important to consult.

Recommended Reading: How To Deal With Asthma Attack Without Inhaler


Most Popular